1 · Diagnosis / Fracture Type
- A distal radius fracture with volar displacement/angulation of the distal fragment — the 'reverse Colles'', sometimes called a 'garden-spade' deformity
2 · Mechanism
- Fall onto the back of a flexed hand (fall onto a flexed wrist), or a direct blow to the dorsal wrist
3 · Examination Findings
- 'Garden-spade' deformity — volar prominence of the distal fragment
- Swelling and tenderness volarly and dorsally over the wrist
4 · Neurovascular Assessment
- Median nerve is at risk given volar displacement — assess median nerve sensation/motor function specifically
- Pulses: palpate distal pulses and compare with the contralateral limb
- Capillary refill: should be <2 seconds distally
- Sensation: test all nerve territories distal to the injury
- Motor function: test relevant muscle groups/tendons distal to the injury
- Skin colour and temperature: compare with the uninjured side
- Always compare with the opposite limb
- Document findings clearly before AND after any reduction, manipulation or splinting
5 · Imaging
- PA and lateral wrist X-rays confirming volar displacement/angulation
6 · ED Treatment
- Analgesia; these fractures are frequently unstable and more likely to need operative fixation than a typical Colles' fracture
7 · Reduction
- Reduction technique is the reverse of Colles' (traction with volar-to-dorsal correction)
- Smith's fractures are inherently unstable — closed reduction alone often does not hold, so early orthopaedic discussion is appropriate even after a technically successful reduction
- Post-reduction X-ray and neurovascular reassessment mandatory
8 · Immobilisation
- Below-elbow backslab with the wrist in a position advised by orthopaedics/local protocol pending fracture clinic review — Smith's fractures often ultimately require surgical fixation
9 · Follow-Up
- Fracture clinic follow-up (not simple VFC) given the higher instability/operative rate
10 · Discuss With Orthopaedics
- Discuss Smith's fractures with orthopaedics — due to inherent instability, many require surgical fixation even after an initially acceptable closed reduction
11 · Red Flags / Urgent Review
- Median nerve compromise
- Loss of reduction/re-displacement
- Open fracture
12 · Discharge Advice & Checklist
- Expect closer fracture-clinic follow-up than a typical Colles' fracture, given the higher instability of this pattern
- ☐ Diagnosis confirmed
- ☐ Appropriate imaging completed
- ☐ Neurovascular status documented
- ☐ Appropriate immobilisation applied
- ☐ Analgesia provided
- ☐ Reduction completed if required
- ☐ Post-reduction imaging completed if required
- ☐ Follow-up arranged
- ☐ Safety-netting provided
- ☐ Patient understands return precautions
13 · Patient Advice
- This fracture pattern is more likely to need an operation than a typical wrist fracture — the fracture clinic will discuss this with you
- Elevation: keep the limb elevated above heart level where possible, especially in the first 48–72 hours, to reduce swelling
- Analgesia: take regular pain relief as advised; use simple analgesia (e.g. paracetamol/ibuprofen if not contraindicated) for breakthrough pain
- Cast/splint care: keep it dry and intact; do not insert anything inside it to scratch itching skin; do not trim, cut or remove it yourself unless told it is removable
- Swelling: some swelling is normal in the first 2–3 days; keep any exposed fingers/toes moving regularly
- Mobilisation/weight-bearing: follow the specific instructions given for this injury
- Seek urgent medical review if: increasing pain not controlled by analgesia, numbness or tingling, colour change (pale, blue or dusky), increasing swelling, a cast/splint that feels tight, fever or signs of infection, or new loss of movement
Not a substitute for institutional protocols, local guidelines or clinical judgment. Always discuss with senior/orthopaedic colleagues where indicated.
← Back to Fracture Management